The Japan Quake, Nuclear Energy and the Daily Kos

As you might imagine, I've been monitoring a lot of stories from around the Web about the situation in Japan. And as you might surmise, while an incident like this is always a cause for concern, it's not a cause for hysteria -- unless of course we're talking about the usual suspects.

One of the more egregious examples out there right now has to be this diary over at Daily Kos that mixes just enough truth with anti-nuke talking points to drum up all the fear and hysteria you might need.

But then again, even in the wake of the over the top analysis, there are a number of readers who are digging in and fighting back. Here are a few samples:

First, allow me to qualify my post by saying that I find the parent diary to be a fairly obnoxious throwback to the type of thinking from the 1970s that bought us another 30 years worth of CO2-spewing coal power, and the fact that it rocketed to the top of the recommended list speaks to Kossack's relative lack of detached analysis on the topic.

[...]

Waste disposal is expensive, yes, but its danger is highly overstated.

First, any byproducts that last for "thousands of years" aren't very radioactive to begin with (otherwise they would disintegrate much faster).

Also, you make it sound like nuclear waste gets dumped in streams, like mine tailings. It doesn't. The Yucca Mountain site was chosen for its geological stability and isolation from groundwater. The relative mass of spent nucler fuel (compared to say, coal slag) is tiny.

We have a similar plan in Canada in the works, basically to bury it a mile deep in a formation that hasn't moved for millions of years. The biggest obstacle to getting it done right now is public acceptance.

[...]

Two hundred have been killed in a Brazilian jetliner crash.

How many people are killed in coal mines every year? How many are injured, maimed or killed on offshore drilling platforms or by gas pipeline explosions, or are hit by coal trains?

What kinds of poisons leach out from the mines; from the oil fields, from the fly-ash disposal pits. What happens when petroleum coke is burned?

We ignore the dangers of everyday life and then use speculation as evidence that nuclear power is unsafe.

There's plenty more where those came from. If you choose to stop by and participate in the debate, please be courteous.